Economic Research Forum (ERF)

The historical roots of state weakness and social inequities in Lebanon

1941
After the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and through the interwar period, Lebanon and much of modern Syria were administered under what was known as the French Mandate. This column explores the legacy of the arrangement, concluding that it had a highly negative impact on the post-independence economic, political, and social development of Lebanon.

In a nutshell

Compared with the North African colonies of the French Empire, the French Mandate’s economy was over-taxed.

Much of the tax revenues were used to finance the French military, and only a smaller part was spent on infrastructure and social services; education and health were made the prerogatives of private and missionary endeavours.

A consequence of this laissez-faire approach was the development of a private education system tilted towards the education of Christians with a startlingly underserved Muslim population.

While we might blame the Ottomans for their lack of investment in the social sectors of the inhabitants of today’s Lebanon and Syria, it is our contention that the French Mandate period played a critical role by failing to ‘guide, assist, and support’ – the roles ascribed to France by the League of Nations – the nascent states in building state institutions and moving away from the Ottoman millet system.

Moreover, the way in which education was privatised led to sharp inequalities in levels of education among different communities, with a massive impact on the post-independence political development of Lebanon.

We base our arguments on the examination of fiscal developments in the state of Lebanon and the four Syrian states that were created during the French Mandate drawing on annual reports by the French authorities to the League of Nations (Ministère des Affaires Étrangères, 1924-38). Our empirical work reveals several insights (Abi-Rached and Diwan, 2022).

First, in contrast to other colonies, where military budgets were financed by the metropole, in the mandated territories, an expansive security apparatus was financed by local taxes. The Armée du Levant was kept large to put down recurrent insurrections. It included expensive French officers and African troops. As a result, to be able to meet military costs, the economy was over-taxed.

The Mandate’s estimated tax revenues per capita in 1925 were around four times those in the African and Asian French colonies. This is more likely to reflect over-taxation, rather than levels of incomes much higher than in French colonies, as Lebanon and Syria’s economies were decimated during the First World War, by destruction, famine, over-taxation and forced conscription into the Ottoman army.

Second, as a share of expenditures, spending on social services was very low in the five states. The share of fiscal expenditures that went to education and health were respectively 3.8% and 1.5%, compared with 9.1% and 6.7% in North Africa. Instead, the budget contributed massively – an astounding level of 74% – to the expenses of the mandatory power, especially its large army and security apparatus. Support for economic development was also much lower than in other colonies.

Share of spending in main sectors (% total expenditures, 1925)

 Infrastructure and productionEducationHealthSecurity sectors
Mandate15.63.81.574.0
North Africa49.89.16.724.7
Indochina37.66.74.341.6
West Central Africa46.43.65.830.7
Madagascar32.56.411.527.8
France41.820.35.931.9

Sources: For the Mandate, data are computed by the authors based on information taken from Rapport à la Société des Nations sur la situation de la Syrie et du Liban (Ministère des Affaires Étrangères, 1928). Data for France and its colonies are taken from Cogneau et al. (2021). Security sectors include judiciary, administration, and security. Production refers to support for the productive sectors.

Third, while social expenditures were low and stagnant across the period, in marked contrast, primary school enrolment expanded rapidly during the Mandate. By 1927, the enrolment rate was already much higher in Lebanon than in any other colony. By 1938, the primary enrolment rate is estimated to have risen to at least 55%. Even though a real effort was made in the last phase of colonisation, after 1955, to improve education in the colonies, only Madagascar reached an enrolment rate by then close to what Lebanon had reached decades earlier.

How did this happen? When looking at the enrolment rates of different communities in different types of schools, we find some striking characteristics. Most students in Lebanon were enrolled in private or foreign schools, each educating about 40% of the student body. Public schools expanded very slowly and never attracted more than 20% of total students.

The second other noteworthy characteristic of the student body is that it was largely made up of Christian students: 75% of students were Christians between 1927 and 1938. This is much more than the estimated proportion of Christians in the population, which in 1932 was estimated at a bit more than 50%.

Third, this imbalance was largely due to the distinct policies of the different educational institutions. The private and especially foreign sectors chose to enrol massively Christian pupils, who oscillated over the period between 70% and 90% of their students. In contrast, the poorer and much smaller public school sector was the main refuge of Muslim students, which constituted 70% of its enrolment.

After the Mandate, Lebanon emerged with an underdeveloped state. It also emerged paradoxically with a much-improved level of education, but this was largely confined to the Christian community. Public education was so rudimentary compared with the private sector that it was unable to catch up even under the presidency of Fouad Chehab (1946-58), who was keen on reinforcing public institutions.

The very biased nature of the performance of the education sector came to influence deeply the social and political evolution of the country. The Mandate was therefore highly influential in its failure to build state institutions and to move the country away from the Ottoman millet system.

Further reading

Abi-Rached, Joelle M., and Ishac Diwan (2022) ‘The Economic Legacy of the French Mandate in Lebanon’, ERF Working Papers No. 1614.

Cogneau, Denis, Yannick Dupraz and Sandrine Mesplé-Somps (2021) ‘Fiscal Capacity and Dualism in Colonial States: The French Empire 1830-1962’, Journal of Economic History 81(2): 441-80.

Ministère des Affaires Étrangères (1924-38) Rapport à la Société des Nations sur la situation de la Syrie et du Liban (Paris: Imprimerie nationale), Bibliothèque Nationale de France.

Traboulsi, Fawwaz (2007) A History of Modern Lebanon, Pluto Press.

Most read

Adoption of decentralised solar energy: lessons from Palestinian households

The experience of Palestinian households offers a compelling case study of behavioural adaptation to energy poverty via solar water heater adoption. This column highlights the key barriers to solar energy adoption in terms of both the socio-economic status and dwellings of potential users. Policy-makers need to address these barriers to ensure a just and equitable transition, particularly for households in conflict-affected areas across the MENA region.

Migration, human capital and labour markets in MENA

Migration is a longstanding and integral part of the MENA region’s economic and social fabric, with profound implications for labour markets and human capital development. To harness the potential of migration for promoting economic and social development, policy-makers must aim to deliver mutual benefits for origin countries, host countries and migrants. Such a triple-win strategy requires better data, investment in return migration, skill partnerships, reduced remittance costs and sustained support for host countries.

Shifting gears: how the private sector can be an engine of growth in MENA

Businesses are a key source of productivity growth, innovation and jobs. But in the Middle East and North Africa, the private sector is not dynamic and the region has a long history of low growth. This column summarises a new report explaining how a brighter future for MENA’s private sector is within reach if governments rethink their role and firms harness talent effectively.

Building net-zero futures: Asian lessons for MENA’s construction sector

Three big economies in Asia are achieving carbon neutrality in construction. This column draws lessons from Japan, Taiwan and Thailand – and explains why, given the vast solar potential and growing focus on environmental, social and governance matters in the Middle East and North Africa, governments in the region must adopt similarly ambitious policies and partnerships.

Losing the key to joy: how oil rents undermine patience and economic growth

How does reliance on oil revenues shape economic behaviour worldwide? This column reports new research showing that oil rents weaken governance, eroding patience – a key driver of economic growth and, according to the 13th century Persian poet Rumi, ‘the key to joy’. Policy measures to counter the damage include enhancing transparency in oil revenue management, strengthening independent oversight institutions and ensuring that sovereign wealth funds have robust rules of governance.

Artificial intelligence and the future of employment in MENA

Artificial intelligence offers opportunities for boosting productivity and innovation. But it also poses substantial threats to traditional employment structures, particularly in economies like those in the Middle East and North Africa that are reliant on low-skill or routine labour. This column explores how AI is likely to affect employment across the region and proposes policy directions for governments to harness AI for inclusive and sustainable economic growth.

Freedom, agency and material conditions: human development in MENA

Conventional approaches to measuring human development, which are primarily centred on income, health and education, provide an incomplete assessment of people’s opportunities to improve their lives. As this column explains, it is essential to understand how institutional and social environments influence individuals’ agency over their development outcomes. Analysis of the diverse recent experiences of Jordan, Lebanon, Morocco and Tunisia illustrates how such an approach can inform policy-making.

Fiscal limits and debt sustainability in MENA economies

Public debt is piling up across the Middle East and North Africa after years of political upheavals, economic shocks and the Covid-19 pandemic. With fiscal space shrinking, governments are under pressure to act. This column explains why for many countries in the region, the room for manoeuvre on the public finances may be smaller than policy-makers think. Urgent action is needed to restore debt sustainability.

Market integration in the Middle East and the Balkans, 1560-1914

Trade has re-emerged as a central issue in global policy debates, as governments debate not only the costs and benefits of trade, but also the underlying determinants of market integration. To inform the discussion, this column reports new research evidence on the experiences of the former Ottoman territories in the Middle East and the Balkans over nearly four centuries, tracing the evolution, drivers and consequences of trade integration across these regions.

From rentier states to innovation economies: is a MENA transition possible?

The combination of climate change, energy price volatility, high unemployment among educated youth, and global technological competition is exposing the vulnerabilities of MENA’s traditional economic structures and the need for structural transformation. This column examines whether such a transition is feasible and the policies that could promote such a shift.