Economic Research Forum (ERF)

France’s headscarf ban: the effects on Muslim integration in the West

7317
What is the effect of religious bans on the economic and social integration of Muslim minorities in Western countries? This column reports evidence on the effects of France’s 2004 legislation banning conspicuous religious symbols in schools, which particularly affected the headscarves worn by Muslim women. There has been a damaging impact on the educational attainment and later life outcomes of young Muslim women affected by the ban.

In a nutshell

The gap in secondary school attainment between Muslim and non-Muslim girls more than doubled after the headscarf ban.

The headscarf ban also hindered economic and social integration in the long term, reducing Muslim women’s labour force participation and their independence.

The negative outcomes of the ban seem to have operated through increased perceptions of discrimination and by casting religion and national identity as incompatible.

Following public outcry, Decathlon – a major French sports company – recently cancelled plans to sell an athletic headscarf.

This is the most recent controversy over Islamic clothing, part of a long-running debate about the integration of Muslims in France. For some, veiling (covering the head or face) symbolises Muslims’ rejection of French values, most notably secularism, and a refusal to assimilate into French culture. Muslims’ preservation of cultural or religious practices is particularly viewed with fear against the backdrop of increasing homegrown radicalisation and terrorism.

To emphasise national values and integrate Muslims into them, France has enacted several policies to regulate Islamic dress, including the 2004 ban on headscarves in schools and the 2010 ban of burqas (full-face covering) in public. Today, about one third of European countries restrict face and head covering in some settings, whether in state institutions (such as courts) or the public sphere more broadly.

Despite the increasing ubiquity of such policies, there is little systematic evidence of their impact. What is the effect of religious bans on the economic and social integration of Muslim minorities?

The answer is not obvious. Many countries have used ‘assimilationist’ strategies to cultivate a national identity. A textbook success case is French nationalisation of rural regions through public education and military conscription. But some research suggests that cultural prohibitions can intensify a minority’s sense of identity.

We bring empirical evidence to bear on this debate in a recent study evaluating a landmark cultural ban. In 2004, the French National Assembly banned conspicuous religious symbols in public primary and secondary schools. Though the law did not single out any particular religious symbol, it was aimed at (and mostly affected) veiled Muslim girls. The law also affected non-veiled Muslim girls, whose behaviour and religious identity came under scrutiny to ensure their compliance with the law.

To study the effects of the headscarf law, we focus on two groups of French women: those born before 1986 and who thus completed secondary school before the law was enacted in 2004; and those born in 1986 and later and who were thus in school during the ban’s implementation.

For pre- and post-ban cohorts, we compare Muslim women’s educational and economic outcomes with those of their non-Muslim peers (using the France’s labour market survey). Then, we assess how the difference in outcomes between Muslim and non-Muslim women changes for cohorts in school during the law’s enactment compared with cohorts in school before the ban.

On average, Muslims in France have been worse off than their non-Muslim counterparts. So we observe a gap in educational attainment (and other outcomes) between Muslim and non-Muslim women for all cohorts in our data.

But if the ban had no effect, the difference in outcomes between Muslim and non-Muslim women would remain unchanged between cohorts born before 1986 – who were not exposed to the 2004 ban – and cohorts born from 1986 onwards – who were exposed to the ban.

Our analysis shows that the law did widen the gap between Muslim and non-Muslim women. Specifically, the gap in secondary school attainment between Muslim and non-Muslim girls more than doubled after the ban.

This was partially due to Muslim women leaving the school system. Their rate of dropping out of secondary school increased by 6 percentage points more than that of their non-Muslim counterparts between the 2003/04 school year (before the ban) and the 2004/05 school year (after the ban).

Affected cohorts of Muslim women also took longer to complete secondary education, further depressing their attainment.

This negative educational shock hindered economic and social integration in the long term. After the ban, the employment gap between Muslim and non-Muslim women widened by a third, while the gap in labour force participation widened by a half. Muslim women were also less independent after the ban; on average, they have more children and are more likely to live with their parents.

What explains these negative outcomes?

First, the ban increased Muslim women’s perceptions of discrimination. The law singled out Muslim schoolgirls who chose to veil and subjected them to differential treatment because of their mode of dress. Public debate accompanying the passage of the law moreover reinforced Muslim girls’ difference.

Both the direct changes in schools and the broader anti-Muslim sentiment made Muslim girls feel targeted. In a social attitudes survey (known as Trajectories and Origins), Muslim women in cohorts affected by the 2004 ban are significantly more likely to report experiencing racism in school and to report lower trust in the French school.

As qualitative interviews reveal, this perceived discrimination placed Muslim girls under considerable psychological stress and disrupted their ability or willingness to perform at school – thereby impairing their educational and long-term economic outcomes.

The second explanation for the negative outcomes from the ban is that it cast religion and national identity as incompatible. The law defined the Muslim headscarf as what Joan Wallach Scott calls a ‘violation of French secularism, and by implication, a sign of the inherent non-Frenchness of anyone who practiced Islam’.

Until that point, French Muslim girls could readily identify as members of both their religious community (by wearing the headscarf) and their country of birth (France). After the ban, they received the signal that their two identities were incompatible and that one could not be French without embracing the principle of secularity as enshrined in the law.

Some Muslim women were thus alienated from broader French society and chose to retreat into their religious communities. Indeed, in the Trajectory and Origins survey, Muslim women affected by the ban are more likely to identify with their father’s country of origin than with France.

Consistent with the idea that the ban was accompanied by general scrutiny that reinforced Muslims’ difference, we find that Muslim men born in 1986/87 – who were in school during the ban’s implementation – experienced a small dip in educational attainment relative to prior cohorts.

But the gap in Muslim and non-Muslim men’s education rebounds to the earlier trend for subsequent cohorts born after 1987. This suggests that once the public debate died down, the ban continued to discriminate against Muslim women by subjecting them to differential treatment in schools, but it did not directly affect Muslim men.

With an estimated 26 million Muslims across Europe and a recent influx of Syrian refugees, the challenge of integration is at the forefront of public policy debate in Europe. ‘Multiculturalist’ policies, which embrace and accept cultural differences, have come under fire, most famously when Germany’s Angela Merkel proclaimed that ‘the multicultural concept is a failure, an absolute failure’.

Despite this proclamation, there is evidence that multiculturalism has modest positive effects for first generation immigrants, though no discernible effects for the second generation. What’s more, individual policies, whether multiculturalist or assimilationist, have not been sufficiently examined.

Our study contributes empirical evidence to this debate on integration. Our analysis of the effect of the 2004 headscarf ban provides causal evidence that policies with an assimilationist character can hinder integration. While they may succeed in their narrower goals (women took off the headscarf in the school, after all), we should consider also their broader consequences, which, in cases like this one, seem to be negative.

This column summarises ‘Political Secularism and Muslim Integration in the West: Assessing the Effects of the French Headscarf Ban’ by Aala Abdelgadir and Vasiliki Fouka.

Most read

EU climate policy: potential effects on the exports of Arab countries

The carbon border adjustment mechanism aims to ensure that Europe’s green objectives are not undermined by the relocation of production to parts of the world with less ambitious climate policies – but it could impose substantial costs on developing countries that export to the European Union. This column examines the potential impact on exporters in the Arab world – and outlines possible policy responses that could mitigate the economic damage.

Green hydrogen production and exports: could MENA countries lead the way?

The Arab region stands at the threshold of a transformative opportunity to become a global leader in green hydrogen production and exports. But as this column explains, achieving this potential will require substantial investments, robust policy frameworks and a commitment to technological innovation.

Financial development, corruption and informality in MENA

Reducing the extent of informality in the Middle East and North Africa would help to promote economic growth. This column reports evidence on how corruption and financial development influence the size of the informal economy in countries across the region. The efficiency of the financial sector in MENA economies reduces the corruption incentive for firms to seek to join and stay in the formal sector.

Freedom: the missing piece in analysis of multidimensional wellbeing

Political philosophy has long emphasised the importance of freedom in shaping a meaningful life, yet it is consistently overlooked in assessments of human wellbeing across multiple dimensions. This column focuses on the freedom to express opinions, noting that it is shaped by both formal laws and informal social dynamics, fluctuating with the changing cultural context, particularly in the age of social media. Data on public opinion in Arab countries over the past decade are revealing about how this key freedom is perceived.

Climate change threats and how the Arab countries should respond

The Arab region is highly vulnerable to extreme events caused by climate change. This column outlines the threats and explores what can be done to ward off disaster, not least moving away from the extraction of fossil fuels and taking advantage of the opportunities in renewable energy generation. This would both mitigate the potential for further environmental damage and act as a catalyst for more and better jobs, higher incomes and improved social outcomes.

Child stunting in Tunisia: an alarming rise

Child stunting in Tunisia seemed to have fallen significantly over the past two decades. But as this column reports, new analysis indicates that the positive trend has now gone dramatically into reverse. Indeed, the evidence is unequivocal: the nutritional health of the country’s youngest citizens is rapidly deteriorating and requires immediate and decisive action.

Exchange rate undervaluation: the impact on participation in world trade

Can currency undervaluation influence participation in world trade through global value chains (GVC)? This column reports new evidence on the positive impact of an undervalued real exchange rate on the involvement of a country’s firms in GVCs. Undervaluation acts as an economy-wide industrial policy, supporting the competitiveness of national exports in foreign markets vis-à-vis those of other countries.

New horizons for economic transformation in the GCC countries

The countries of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) have historically relied on hydrocarbons for economic growth. As this column explains ahead of a high-level ERF policy seminar in Dubai, emerging technologies like artificial intelligence, blockchain and robotics – what some call the fourth industrial revolution – present a unique opportunity for the region to reduce its dependence on oil and make the transition to a knowledge-based economy.

Shifting public trust in governments across the Arab world

The Arab Spring, which began over a decade ago, was driven by popular distrust in governments of the region. The column reports on how public trust has shifted since then, drawing on survey data collected soon after the uprising and ten years later. The findings reveal a dynamic and often fragile landscape of trust in Arab governments from the early 2010s to the early 2020s. Growing distrust across many countries should raise concerns about future political and social instability.

Egypt’s labour market: new survey data for evidence-based decision-making

As Egypt faces substantial social and economic shifts, understanding the labour market is crucial for designing policies that promote employment and inclusive economic growth. This column introduces the latest wave of the Egypt Labor Market Panel Survey, which provides fresh, nationally representative data that are vital for examining these dynamics.




LinkedIn