Economic Research Forum (ERF)

Challenges of GCC investment in the energy transition

4300
The countries of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) have identified the energy transition as a crucial area of growth and are investing heavily in a diverse array of projects. However, as this column explains, the region faces a number of challenges in making a success of these investments, most notably its current dependence on fossil fuels, a lack of infrastructure and technical expertise, the high upfront costs, and geopolitical tensions.

In a nutshell

Renewable energy projects promise great economic benefits in terms of driving green growth and achieving sustainable development; they are of paramount importance for reducing harmful gas emissions, especially through diversifying economies and investing in energy efficiency.

To consolidate security and political stability in the region, governments of GCC countries need to manage their political and economic systems amid the global transition away from carbon-based economies.

The success of the transition will depend on governments’ capacity to deliver economic diversification, investment in sustainable infrastructure, and the development of renewable energy to enhance resilience and adapt to climate-related risks.

All the countries in the GCC region have announced goals for raising the share of renewable energy in their energy mix. Bahrain recently doubled its targets to achieve 20% of its total energy mix by 2035; Kuwait has announced a target of 15% by 2030; Oman has announced a target of 10% by 2025 and 30% by 2030; and Qatar has announced a target of 20% by 2030. Saudi Arabia has set the most powerful target in the Gulf, with a goal of generating 50% renewable energy for electricity by 2030, followed by the United Arab Emirates (UAE), which has set a clean energy target of 44% by 2050.

The GCC countries have started the energy transition and they are continuing the implementation process through large-scale renewable projects (see Table 1). Each country has its own unique initiatives and goals to shift towards cleaner and more sustainable energy sources.

Table 1: The largest energy megaprojects in the GCC countries

Green opportunities

The GCC region presents significant opportunities for investing in the energy transition. Indeed, the region is endowed with abundant renewable energy resources, particularly solar and wind energy (Basha et al, 2021). The use of these resources can help to achieve lower reliance on fossil fuels and contribute to the mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions.

Furthermore, investing in renewable energy can create job opportunities, enhance energy security, and improve air quality (Alnaser et al, 2022). The GCC countries can also leverage sustainable energy to drive green growth and achieve sustainable development by diversifying their economies. It will be possible to create new jobs, reduce energy costs, improve air quality and attract foreign investment by investing in renewable energy, energy efficiency, sustainable transport and the circular economy, as well as through international cooperation.

Key challenges

Among the main challenges is the current dominance of fossil fuels in the energy mix, which has led to a lack of incentives and policies to promote renewable energy. The presence of high hydrocarbon subsidies and a low electricity tariff structure also discourage the adoption of renewable energy technologies (Al-Sarihi and Mansouri, 2022).

The shift to alternative revenue sources requires careful social and economic preparation.  Novertheless, the harsh climatic conditions in the GCC region stand as an obstacle to the efficient operation and maintenance of renewable energy facilities, and they complicate the process. The lack of infrastructure combined with the high upfront cost of investment can also pose additional challenges to the energy transition in the region.

The GCC and the geopolitics of the energy transition

The Gulf region is at the core of the global waves of energy and climate change-related geopolitical development. Political tensions and geopolitical rivalries within the region hinder the development of a cooperative approach to mitigate the effects of climate change and impede integrated regional collaborations (Beni et al, 2021).

To consolidate their security and political stability in the region, the GCC countries should balance their relations with the regional powers, respond to the fallout of regional and global crises, and manage their political and economic systems amid the global shift away from carbon-based energy sources. The Gulf states will try to stay in a good position internationally as oil and gas are managed outside the global economy through multilateral climate diplomacy (Strategic Comments, 2022).

The Gulf states and the post-oil era

The Gulf states recognise the importance of preparing for the post-carbon era, and seeking to diversify their economies and achieve sustainability. The success of this transition will depend on the countries’ capability of fulfilling various conditions, including diversifying their economies, ecologically modernising Gulf societies, reducing environmental risks, enhancing GCC-wide cooperation (Al-Saidi, 2020) and promoting research in renewable energy.

The success of the transition will also depend on the capacity of the GCC countries to mitigate environmental risks. Indeed, governments should use a range of economic tools that can play a crucial role in promoting climate change mitigation and adaptation in the region, including subsidy reform, green bonds, energy efficiency standards and carbon taxes (Miniaoui, 2023).

Further reading

Alnaser, NW, HM Albuflasa and WE Alnaser (2022) ‘The Transition in Solar and Wind Energy Use in Gulf Cooperation Council Countries (GCCC)’, Renewable Energy and Environmental Sustainability 7: 4.Al-Saidi, M (2020) ‘From Economic to Extrinsic Values of Sustainable Energy: Prestige, Neo-Rentierism, and Geopolitics of the Energy Transition in the Arabian Peninsula’, Energies 13(21): 5545.

Al-Sarihi, A, and N Mansouri (2022) Renewable Energy Development in the Gulf Cooperation Council Countries: Status, Barriers, and Policy Options’, Energies 5(15): 1923.

Basha, J, T Jafary, R Vasudevan, J Bahadur, MA Ajmi et al (2021) ‘Potential of Utilization of Renewable Energy Technologies in Gulf Countries’, Sustainability 13(18): 10261.

Beni, AN, N Marriner, A Sharifi, J Azizpour, K Kabiri, M Djamali and A Kirman (2021) ‘Climate Change: A Driver Of Future Conflicts in the Persian Gulf Region?’, Heliyon 2(7): e06288.

Miniaoui, H (2023) ‘Climate Change in the Middle East and North Africa: Between the repercussions of a lived reality and opportunities for a brighter future’, ERF Policy Brief No. 109.

Strategic Comments (2022) ‘The Arab Gulf states and the geopolitics of the energy transition’, Strategic Comments28:2.

Tags: , , , , , ,

Most read

Sanctions and the shrinking size of Iran’s middle class

International sanctions imposed on Iran from 2012 have reduced the size of the country’s middle class, according to new research summarised in this column. The findings highlight the profound social consequences of economic pressure, not least given the crucial role of that segment of society for national innovation, growth and stability. The study underscores the need for policies to safeguard the civilian population in countries targeted by sanctions.

Artificial intelligence and the renewable energy transition in MENA

Artificial intelligence has the potential to bridge the gap between abundant natural resources and the pressing need for reliable, sustainable power in the Middle East and North Africa. This column outlines the constraints and proposes policies that can address the challenges of variability of renewable resources and stress on power grids, and support the transformation of ‘sunlight’ to ‘smart power’.

Green jobs for MENA in the age of AI: crafting a sustainable labour market

Arab economies face a dual transformation: the decarbonisation imperative driven by climate change; and the rapid digitalisation brought by artificial intelligence. This column argues that by strategically managing the green-AI nexus, policy-makers in the region can position their countries not merely as followers adapting to global mandates but as leaders in sustainable innovation.

Egypt’s forgotten democratisation: a challenge to modern myths about MENA

A widely held narrative asserts that countries in the Middle East are inevitably authoritarian. This column reports new research that tracks Egyptian parliamentarians since 1824 to reveal that the region’s struggle with democracy is not in fact about cultural incompatibility: it’s about colonialism disrupting home-grown democratic movements and elite conflicts being resolved through disenfranchisement rather than power-sharing.

MENA integration into global value chains and sustainable development

Despite the geopolitical advantages, abundant natural resources and young populations of many countries in the Middle East and North Africa, they remain on the periphery of global value chains, the international networks of production and service activities that now dominate the world economy. This column explains the positive impact of integration into GVCs on exports and employment; its role in technology transfer and capacity upgrading; and the structural barriers that constrain the region’s involvement. Greater GVC participation can help to deliver structural transformation and sustainable development.

Arab youth and the future of work

The Arab region’s labour markets are undergoing a triple transformation: demographic, digital and green. As this column explains, whether these forces evolve into engines of opportunity or drivers of exclusion for young people will hinge on how swiftly and coherently policy-makers can align education, technology and employment systems to foster adaptive skills, inclusive institutions and innovation-led pathways to decent work.

Wrong finance in a broken multilateral system: red flags from COP30-Belém

With the latest global summit on climate action recently wrapped up, ambitious COP pledges and initiatives continue to miss delivery due to inadequate commitments, weak operationalisation and unclear reporting systems. As this column reports, flows of climate finance remain skewed: loans over grants; climate mitigation more than climate adaptation; and weak accountability across mechanisms. Without grant-based finance, debt relief, climate-adjusted lending and predictable multilateral flows, implementation of promises will fail.

Why political connections are driving business confidence in MENA

This column reports the findings of a new study of how the political ties of firms in the Middle East and North Africa boost business confidence. The research suggests that this optimism is primarily driven by networked access to credit and lobbying, underscoring the need for greater transparency and institutional reform in corporate governance.

Digitalising governance in MENA: opportunities for social justice

Can digital governance promote social justice in MENA – or does it risk deepening inequality and exclusion? This column examines the evolution of digital governance in three sub-regions – Egypt, Jordan and the countries of the Gulf Cooperation Council – highlighting how data practices, transparency mechanisms and citizen trust shape the social outcomes of technological reform.