Economic Research Forum (ERF)

Physicians’ incentives and rising births by c-section: evidence from Iran

735
In many countries of the Middle East and North Africa, rates of caesarean deliveries are above what is recommended by the World Health Organization. This column summarises new research that evaluates the effects of a major healthcare policy in Iran in which doctors and patients received financial incentives to opt for vaginal delivery instead of c-section.

In a nutshell

Several countries in the MENA region are among those globally with the highest rates of birth by c-section, including Egypt, Iran and Turkey.

It is well established by research in health economics that financial incentives of doctors play a major role in inducing the demand for certain procedures in the grey areas of medical guidelines.

A healthcare policy in Iran that provided both doctors and patients with financial incentives to opt for vaginal delivery was effective in reducing the rate of c-sections, especially among first-time mothers.

A great portion of medical practice lies in the grey area of medical guidelines where the economic incentives of healthcare providers play a crucial role in the type of treatment that the patient receives.

Different procedures for childbirth are a classic example of a grey area of medicine. Apart from extreme emergency cases where a c-section is inevitably lifesaving, many infants can be born either by vaginal delivery or c-section. But there is no clear cut-off after which the medical guidelines dictate a certain procedure and usually the doctor is responsible for choosing between alternative options. That is why there is a large variation in c-section rates across doctors, hospitals, regions and countries.

In addition, these two childbirth procedures are not exactly equal either for the doctor or for the mother and baby. C-section is usually a highly reimbursed procedure. On the other hand, vaginal delivery is time-consuming, imposes high stress levels, is unpredictable and has more cases of judicial problems.

For these reasons, gynaecologists have a preference for c-section in marginal cases. For example, in a seminal study, Gruber and Owings (1994) show that American gynaecologists compensated the income shock that resulted from the decline in fertility by substituting vaginal deliveries with highly reimbursed c-sections.

But like any other surgery, c-sections have their own risks. The recovery period from c-section is much longer than vaginal delivery for the mother. There are also some risks to the newborn, especially if the c-section is planned unnecessarily earlier than the due date. Therefore, many medical guidelines try to control the c-section rate and target some form of ideal c-section rate in the country.

In our research, we study a large-scale healthcare reform to control the rising c-section rate in Iran, a country that had one of the highest rates in the world. In 2014, 55% of births were delivered by c-section. This compares with the World Health Organization (WHO) recommended rate of 10-15%, the average rate in OECD countries (27%) and in the MENA region (29%).

Iran’s high rate is partly due to medical guidelines that give greater freedom to doctors to induce demand for a certain type of procedure. In addition, doctors were allowed to plan the delivery for the 38th week of the gestation age while many clinical guidelines in developed countries restrict caesarean delivery and labour induction prior to the 39th week. As more than 90% of women go through the natural process of labour after the 38th week of pregnancy, such a high c-section rate is not achievable without planning many deliveries early.

The programme in Iran started on 5 May 2014 in all public hospitals in the country. The c-section rate in public hospitals was lower than the national average, although still reached as high as 47%.

Following the programme, vaginal deliveries became free of charge, the performing doctors received bonus payments for vaginal delivery, and they were subject to an annual quota for the maximum number of caesarean deliveries.  If the doctor’s annual c-section rate exceeded 45%, she would not get paid for the extra procedure performed.

In our study, we show that the programme was effective in reducing the c-section rate especially among first-time mothers, who have fewest risk factors for c-section. Their rate dropped from 48% to 35% in less than six months.

We show that the financial incentives of doctors played a crucial role in the effectiveness of the programme. Those doctors who had a very high c-section rate responded sharply to the incentives and they were the driving forces of the reform.

In terms of health outcomes, apart from a slight increase in the gestation age and infant birth weight, we could not observe any other significant effect. After the reform, fewer births were planned early term (that is, at the 38th week of the gestational age), hence we identified the effect on birth weight. But we failed to identify any effect on mortality rate, hospitalisation and other health measures of the infants.

The programme was not harmful in terms of immediate health outcomes, although it had some unintended effects such as shifting high skilled doctors out of public hospitals.

The programme will have long-run effects that are not captured by our analysis of three years around the reform. First, c-section is a persistent procedure; in many medical guidelines, elective repeated c-sections should be discussed with mothers who have had a previous caesarean. So, we expect further reduction in the c-section rate of higher order births.

Second, c-section has a negative effect on the subsequent chances of contraception (Halla et al, 2016). Therefore, the programme will have long-run effects on the fertility rate and labour market decisions of women.

This policy evaluation can be used by other countries that have similar problems in their healthcare sector and intend to control the c-section rate, which is rising in almost all countries. To name a few, Korea, Mexico and Turkey have c-section rates above 45%.

In addition, our study contributes to the well-studied concept of physician-induced demand and its consequences for patients. Medical guidelines should provide the basis for an optimal treatment while compensating the doctors with fair pay rates.

 

This column is based on a recently published paper: Pilvar, H, and K Yousefi (2021) ‘Changing Physicians’ Incentives to Control the C-section Rate: Evidence from a Major Health Care Reform in Iran’, Journal of Health Economics 102514.

 

Further reading

Gruber, J, and M Owings (1996) ‘Physician Financial Incentives and Cesarean Section Delivery’, RAND Journal of Economics 27(1): 99-123.

Halla, M, H Mayr, GJ Pruckner and P García-Gómez (2020) ‘Cutting fertility? Effects of cesarean deliveries on subsequent fertility and maternal labor supply’, Journal of Health Economics 72: 102325.

Tags: , , , ,

  • Hanifa Pilvar
    Hanifa Pilvar
    PhD candidate in Economics, School of Economics and Finance, Queen Mary University of London
  • Kowsar Yousefi
    Kowsar Yousefi
    Associate professor of Economics, Department of Economics, University of Tehran

Most read

Egypt’s labour market: new survey data for evidence-based decision-making

As Egypt faces substantial social and economic shifts, understanding the labour market is crucial for designing policies that promote employment and inclusive economic growth. This column introduces the latest wave of the Egypt Labor Market Panel Survey, which provides fresh, nationally representative data that are vital for examining these dynamics.

The evolution of labour supply in Egypt

Egypt stands at a critical point in its demographic and labour market evolution. As this column explains, while fertility rates have dropped, reducing long-term demographic pressures, the ‘echo generation’, children of the youth bulge, will soon enter the labour market, intensifying the need for policies to accelerate job creation. At the same time, participation in the labour force, particularly among women and young people, is declining, partly as a result of discouragement.

Towards a productive, inclusive and green economy in MENA

Decarbonisation of the global economy is a huge opportunity for countries in the Middle East and North Africa. As this column explains, they can supercharge their development by breaking into fast-growing industries that will help the world to reduce its emissions and reach net zero, as well as offering greater employment opportunities and new export lines. Micro, small and medium enterprises in the region can lead the transition to a cleaner and sustainable future, but this may require the formation of clusters of firms that overcome some of the constraints that their limited size could involve.

Participation of Arab countries in global value chains

To what extent are countries in the Arab region participating in the global value chains (GVCs) that now dominate world trade? What are the main determinants of engagement in GVCs? And what are the expected benefits for Arab countries from joining them? This column answers these questions, concluding that it is important to focus on the products in which countries both enjoy a natural comparative advantage and can increase domestic value added in the intermediate and final parts of the production process.

Climate change: a growing threat to sustainable development in Tunisia

Tunisia’s vulnerability to extreme weather events is intensifying, placing immense pressure on vital sectors such as agriculture, energy and water resources, exacerbating inequalities and hindering social progress. This column explores the economic impacts of climate change on the country, its implications for achieving the sustainable development goals, and the urgent need for adaptive strategies and policy interventions.

Growth in the Middle East and North Africa

What is the economic outlook for the Middle East and North Africa? How is the current conflict centred in Gaza affecting economies in the region? What are the potential long-term effects of conflict on development? And which strategies can MENA countries adopt to accelerate economic growth? This column outlines the findings in the World Bank’s latest half-yearly MENA Economic Update, which answers these questions and more.

Assessing Jordan’s progress on the sustainable development goals

Global, regional and national assessments of countries’ progress towards reaching the sustainable development goals do not always tell the same story. This column examines the case of Jordan, which is among the world’s leaders in statistical performance on the SDGs.

Rising influence: women’s empowerment within Arab households

In 2016 and again in 2022, a reliable poll of public opinion in the Arab world asked respondents in seven countries whether they agreed with the statement that ‘a man should have final say in all decisions concerning the family’. As this column reports, the changing balance of responses between the two surveys gives an indication of whether there been progress in the distribution of decision-making within households towards greater empowerment of women.

Unleashing the potential of Egyptian exports for sustainable development

Despite several waves of trade liberalisation, Egypt’s integration in the world economy has remained modest. In addition, the structure of its exports has not changed and remains largely dominated by traditional products. This column argues that the government should develop a new export strategy that is forward-looking by taking account not only of the country’s comparative advantage, but also how global demand evolves. The strategy should also be more inclusive and more supportive of sustainable development.

International and regional financial integration in MENA

What are the effects of financial integration at both the regional and international level on the domestic economies of the Middle East and North Africa? This column summarises new research evidence on this question. The results suggest that while regional financial integration offers substantial benefits, ‘too much’ international integration could hinder financial development.