Economic Research Forum (ERF)

Do capital inflows cause industrialisation or de-industrialisation?

946
There is a clear appeal for emerging and developing economies, including those in MENA, to finance investment in manufacturing industry at home with capital inflows from overseas. But as the evidence reported in this column indicates, this is a potentially risky strategy: rather than promoting industrialisation, capital flows can actually lead to lower manufacturing value added and/or a reallocation of resources towards industries with lower technology intensity.

In a nutshell

According to conventional economic analysis, international financial flows stimulate industrialisation because the movement of capital provides efficient capital allocation, reduces the cost of capital, and encourages investment and growth.

New empirical evidence suggests that capital inflows lead to de-industrialisation; this is the case for medium and high-tech manufacturing industry in advanced and emerging economies, and for low-tech manufacturing industry in the Middle East and North Africa.

In emerging market and developing economies, capital flows tend to promote low-tech manufacturing, which suggests that capital inflows tend to reallocate resources from medium and high-tech manufacturing to low-tech manufacturing.

Conventional economic analysis suggests that a country’s openness to international financial flows promotes industrialisation because the movement of capital provides efficient capital allocation, reduces the cost of capital, and encourages investment and growth.

But recent research, including a study by Benigno et al (2015), is much more sceptical about the benefits of financial openness. Incorporation of capital flow management measures, including capital controls, in the suggested policy toolkit of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) can be regarded as a reflection of the shift in thinking.

Indeed, a prominent study by Rodrik (2016) finds that since the 1980s, developing economies have tended to experience declining shares of manufacturing value added in GDP – a phenomenon known as ‘de-industrialisation’. This trend corresponds to the onset of the era of globalisation, which gained momentum during the post-1990s period (Haraguchi et al, 2019).

Rodrik’s results indicate that while trade globalisation promotes manufacturing industry, openness to international financial flows – financial globalisation – leads to de-industrialisation.

This can be explained by the financial ‘Dutch disease’ argument of Corden (1994) and Palma (2005), according to which international capital flows cause exchange rate appreciation, which in turn leads to a contraction in the tradable sector. In this vein, the results of Benigno et al (2015) show that capital inflows tend to allocate resources out of manufacturing.

Figure 1: Evolution of manufacturing industry value added (MVA)

My new research looks at the impact of capital inflows on a range of countries over a 30-year period (Taşdemir, 2023).

Figure 1 shows the evolution of average manufacturing value added (as a percentage of GDP) over the period 1990-2019. Considering the heterogeneity of the whole sample of 84 countries, my study disaggregates the set into advanced economies (ADV), emerging market and developing economies (EMDE), and economies of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA).

Accordingly, manufacturing value added appears to diminish over the years in advanced and emerging economies. Compared with the 1990s, the gap between emerging and advanced economies tends to increase during the more recent two decades.

In MENA, manufacturing value added seems to be much lower than in advanced and emerging economies. Surprisingly, average manufacturing value added is almost the same in advanced economies and MENA during the most recent decade. Considering the decelerating trend in manufacturing value added implies de-industrialisation, this figure indicates that it is sharper in advanced economies.

Figure 2: Manufacturing industry across technology intensity levels

The aggregate manufacturing value added exhibits widespread heterogeneity in terms of technology intensity levels. Taking this important point into consideration, my study disaggregates manufacturing value added into medium and high-tech (MH-MVA) and low-tech (L-MVA) manufacturing industries.

Figure 2 represents the shares of MH-MVA and L-MVA in the aggregate manufacturing industry over the years. Accordingly, the share of L-MVA is substantially higher than MH-MVA in the whole sample. This trend is also evident for emerging economies and MENA. The gap between MH-MVA and L-MVA is much lower in advanced economies compared with emerging economies and MENA.

Figure 3: Evolution of capital flows

Figure 3 illustrates the evolution of average capital flows, defined as the sum of the current account deficit and the change in reserves. Capital flows tend to increase until 2007 and then begin to decrease in emerging economies. Average capital flows also appear to diminish in advanced economies. In MENA, capital flows initially increase, then decrease up to the first half of the 2000s, and subsequently appear to increase during the rest of the period.

Compared with advanced and emerging economies, capital flows seem to be much more volatile in MENA. The figure also indicates that average capital flows are almost consistently positive in emerging economies and MENA, while they are negative in advanced economies. This may suggest that capital tends to move from advanced economies to emerging economies and MENA.

Figure 4: Scatterplot of capital flows with MVA, MH-MVA and L-MVA

Figure 4 shows the scatterplot of capital flows with manufacturing value added, MH-MVA and L-MVA for the whole sample. Accordingly, there is a negative relationship between capital flows and manufacturing value added. This may imply that an increase in capital flows tends to divert resources away from the manufacturing industry. This negative association is also evident for MH-MVA, aligning with the financial Dutch disease argument. But there is a positive relationship between capital flows and L-MVA, consistent with the theoretical benefits of financial openness.

In line with Figure 4, the empirical findings of the research suggest that capital flows lead to lower manufacturing value added in advanced, economies, emerging economies and MENA. This result contradicts the theoretical benefits of financial openness and may imply that capital flows cause financial Dutch disease by diverting resources away from manufacturing value added. Consequently, capital flows induce currency appreciation, which reduces profitability and investment opportunities in the tradable manufacturing sector.

This finding may also imply that capital flows lead to services becoming a more important part of the economy, which is the mirror image of de-industrialisation. The negative relationship between capital flows and manufacturing value added holds true for MH-MVA in advanced and emerging economies, and for L-MVA in MENA. But capital flows promote L-MVA in emerging economies, indicating a shift of resources from MH-MVA to L-MVA in this group.

Given that MH-MVA has higher productivity, de-industrialisation in MH-MVA is expected to increase productivity and income disparities. To mitigate the side effects of financial openness, the economies may consider capital flow management measures including capital controls as suggested by the IMF.

Additionally, sound and credible macroeconomic policies, flexible exchange rate arrangements, and enhanced financial development are expected to minimise the undesirable side effects of capital flows.

Consistent with remarks by Aiginger and Rodrik (2020), policy-makers may prioritise industrialisation in economic and social policies, with collaboration between the public and private sectors. Also, the movement from ‘turbo globalisation’ to ‘responsible globalisation’ along with international cooperation and solutions to problems related to globalisation may increase the success of policies.

The results of the new study imply that it is possible to finance manufacturing investment with capital flows, but it could be risky.

Further reading

Aiginger, K, and D Rodrik (2020) ‘Rebirth of industrial policy and an agenda for the twenty-first century’, Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade 20: 189-207.

Benigno, G, N Converse and L Fornaro (2015) ‘Large capital inflows, sectoral allocation, and economic performance’, Journal of International Money and Finance 55: 60-87.

Corden, WM (1994) Economic Policy, Exchange Rates, and the International System, Oxford University Press.

Haraguchi, N, B Martorano and M Sanfilippo (2019) ‘What factors drive successful industrialization? Evidence and implications for developing countries’, Structural Change and Economic Dynamics 49: 266-76.

Palma, GJ (2005) ‘Four sources of “de-industrialisation” and a new concept of the “Dutch disease”’, in: Ocampo, J (ed.) Beyond Reforms: Structural Dynamics and Macroeconomic Vulnerability, Stanford University Press and World Bank.

Rodrik, D (2016) ‘Premature deindustrialization’, Journal of Economic Growth 21: 1-33.

Taşdemir, F (2023) ‘Do Capital Flows Cause (De-)Industrialization?’, ERF Working Paper No 1693.

Tags: , ,

  • Fatma Taşdemir
    Fatma Taşdemir
    Faculty Member, Department of International Trade and Business, Sinop University

Most read

Trust in Lebanon’s public institutions: a challenge for the new leadership

Lebanon’s new leadership confronts daunting economic challenges amid geopolitical tensions across the wider region. As this column explains, understanding what has happened over the past decade to citizens’ trust in key public institutions – parliament, the government and the armed forces – will be a crucial part of the policy response.

Climate change: a growing threat to sustainable development in Tunisia

Tunisia’s vulnerability to extreme weather events is intensifying, placing immense pressure on vital sectors such as agriculture, energy and water resources, exacerbating inequalities and hindering social progress. This column explores the economic impacts of climate change on the country, its implications for achieving the sustainable development goals, and the urgent need for adaptive strategies and policy interventions.

Small businesses in the Great Lockdown: lessons for crisis management

Understanding big economic shocks like Covid-19 and how firms respond to them is crucial for mitigating their negative effects and accelerating the post-crisis recovery. This column reports evidence on how small and medium-sized enterprises in Tunisia’s formal business sector adapted to the pandemic and the lockdown – and draws policy lessons for when the next crisis hits.

Assessing Jordan’s progress on the sustainable development goals

Global, regional and national assessments of countries’ progress towards reaching the sustainable development goals do not always tell the same story. This column examines the case of Jordan, which is among the world’s leaders in statistical performance on the SDGs.

Qatarisation: playing the long game on workforce nationalisation

As national populations across the Gulf have grown and hydrocarbon reserves declined, most Gulf countries have sought to move to a more sustainable economic model underpinned by raising the share of citizens in the productive private sector. But, as this column explains, Qatar differs from its neighbours in several important ways that could render aggressive workforce nationalization policies counterproductive. In terms of such policies, the country should chart its own path.

The threat of cybercrime in MENA economies

The MENA region’s increasing access to digital information and internet usage has led to an explosion in e-commerce and widespread interest in cryptocurrencies. At the same time, cybercrime, which includes hacking, malware, online fraud and harassment, has spread across digital networks. This column outlines the challenges.

Economic consequences of the 2003 Bam earthquake in Iran

Over the decades, Iran has faced numerous devastating natural disasters, including the deadly 2003 Bam earthquake. This column reports evidence on the unexpected economic boost in Bam County and its neighbours after the disaster – the result of a variety of factors, including national and international aid, political mobilisation and the region’s cultural significance. Using data on the intensity of night-time lights in a geographical area, the research reveals how disaster recovery may lead to a surprising economic rebound.

Macroeconomic policy-making for sustainable development in Egypt

In recent years, economic policy in Egypt has been focused primarily on macroeconomic stabilisation to curb inflation, to reduce the fiscal deficit and the current account deficit, and to increase GDP growth. As this column explains, this has come at the expense of the country’s progress on the Sustainable Development Goals, which is rather modest compared with other economies in the region or at the same income level. Sustainable development needs to be more integrated with the conception and implementation of fiscal and monetary policies.

The impact of climate change and resource scarcity on conflict in MENA

The interrelationships between climate change, food production, economic instability and violent conflict have become increasingly relevant in recent decades, with climate-induced economic shocks intensifying social and political tensions, particularly in resource-constrained regions like MENA. This column reports new evidence on the impact of climate change on economic and food production outcomes – and how economic stability, agricultural productivity and shared water resources affect conflict. While international aid, economic growth and food security reduce the likelihood of conflict, resource scarcity and shared water basins contribute to high risks of conflict.

Qatar’s pursuit of government excellence: promises and pitfalls

As Qatar seeks to make the transition from a hydrocarbon-based economy to a diversified, knowledge-based economy, ‘government excellence’ has been identified as a key strategic objective. This column reports what government effectiveness means in terms of delivery of public services, digitalisation of services, and control of corruption – and outlines the progress made to date on these development priorities and what the country needs to do to meet its targets.